Evidence Record

UK Health and Safety Executive  ·  2021  ·  Cannot prove

National Grid Gas: £4M HSE Fine

UK HSE Prosecution, 2021

Compliance records

What happened

When National Grid Gas sold its gas distribution operations to Cadent Gas in 2016, safety maintenance records for 769 high-rise residential buildings were not properly transferred. The following year, when the HSE requested those records to verify that required safety inspections of gas risers had been carried out, the company could not demonstrate that the buildings had ever been inspected, maintained, or surveyed. No harm had occurred at those buildings. The fine of £4 million, one of the largest HSE fines of 2021, was imposed purely because the safety inspections could not be evidenced retroactively. The judge's reasoning was explicit: the absence of records was itself evidence of inadequate safety management. A blockchain-timestamped record of each inspection, created at the time of completion, would have survived the corporate transfer and provided irrefutable proof that the inspections had occurred and when.

Outcome

£4 million fine, one of the largest HSE fines of 2021. No harm had occurred. The fine was imposed purely because safety could not be evidenced retroactively.

Sources

Authority source confirmed

Public proof. Private work.

immut records a cryptographic hash of your file on the public XRP Ledger at the moment of creation. The timestamp is independently verifiable by anyone.

Anchor your evidence

Evidence Record

See all 43 rulings on record.

Jurisdiction filters, evidence-type filters, and authority sources linked on every case.